Discover the pros and cons of selling on Amazon vs Walmart. Complete 2025 comparison guide to choose the best e-commerce platform for your business.

Introduction

Did you know that over 60% of global e-commerce sales flow through just two giants: Amazon and Walmart? If you’re an entrepreneur or small business owner looking to expand your online presence, this statistic reveals the crucial importance of making the right platform choice.

The question is no longer whether to sell online, but where to sell to maximize your profits and visibility. Amazon dominates with its 300 million active users, while Walmart Marketplace is rapidly gaining ground with 79% growth in 2023.

In this article, we’ll break down the advantages and disadvantages of each platform to help you make the decision that will transform your business. You’ll discover which marketplace best fits your industry, budget, and growth objectives.

Amazon:The Undisputed E-commerce Giant

Amazon’s Advantages

Exceptional Reach and Traffic Amazon attracts over 2.7 billion monthly visitors, offering massive exposure for your products. This gigantic audience represents sales potential that few other platforms can match.

FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) Program Amazon’s logistics service handles storage, packaging, and shipping of your products. Over 89% of Prime sellers use FBA, benefiting from fast delivery that boosts conversions by 20-30%.

Sophisticated Advertising Tools Amazon PPC allows precise audience targeting with sponsored campaigns. Sellers using Amazon advertising see an average 50% increase in sales.

Amazon’s Disadvantages

Fierce Competition With over 9.7 million active sellers, standing out becomes a major challenge. Prices are constantly driven down, reducing profit margins.

High Fees Amazon’s commissions range from 8% to 45% depending on categories, plus FBA fees. These costs can represent up to 35% of your revenue.

Algorithm Dependency Frequent Amazon algorithm changes can tank your sales overnight, creating constant uncertainty for sellers.

Walmart Marketplace: The Promising Alternative

Walmart’s Advantages

Less Competition Walmart has only 150,000 third-party sellers—65 times fewer than Amazon. This difference offers a unique visibility opportunity with less direct competition.

Competitive Fees Walmart commissions range from 6% to 20%, significantly less than Amazon. This fee structure better preserves your profit margins.

Explosive Growth Walmart Marketplace shows 79% growth in 2023, attracting more and more consumers seeking Amazon alternatives.

High Quality Standards Walmart maintains strict seller selection criteria, creating a less saturated and higher-quality environment.

Walmart’s Disadvantages

Strict Approval Process Walmart only accepts sellers by invitation or after rigorous application. This process can take several weeks and isn’t guaranteed.

Lower Traffic With 410 million monthly visitors, Walmart generates 6 times less traffic than Amazon, limiting your potential exposure.

Less Developed Tools Walmart’s advertising platform is less mature than Amazon PPC, offering fewer targeting and optimization options.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Amazon vs Walmart

Key Decision Criteria

Choose Amazon if:

• • You prioritize maximum sales volume

• • Your marketing budget is substantial

• • You sell products with high margins

• • You can handle intense competition

Choose Walmart if:

• • You’re looking for better profit margins

• • You prefer less competition

• • Your strategy focuses on quality over volume

• • You’re primarily targeting the US market

Sectors Favored by Each Platform

Amazon excels in:

• • Electronics and tech

• • Books and media

• • Beauty and health products

• • Sports and leisure items

Walmart performs well in:

• • Food and fresh products

• • Home goods

• • Clothing and accessories

• • Toys and children’s items

Winning Strategies for Each Platform

Amazon Optimization

Deep Keyword Research Use tools like Helium 10 or Jungle Scout to identify high-potential, low-competition keywords.

Product Listing Optimization Perfect your titles, descriptions, and images. Products with optimized listings see an average 30% sales increase.

Proactive Review Management Maintain a minimum 4.5-star rating. 94% of consumers avoid products with less than 4 stars.

Walmart Optimization

Focus on Quality Offer high-quality products with detailed descriptions. Walmart values premium customer experience.

Optimize Your Pricing Take advantage of lower competition to maintain healthy margins while staying competitive.

Leverage Cross-selling Develop complementary product lines to increase your average order value and visibility.

Multi-Platform Approach: The Ultimate Strategy

Why choose when you can conquer both? Many successful businesses adopt a multi-marketplace strategy:

Strategic Distribution

• • High-margin, high-volume products → Amazon

• • Premium and niche products → Walmart

• • New product testing → Walmart (less risky)

• • Established products → Amazon (maximize sales)

Cross-Platform Synergies Customer data from one platform can inform your strategy on the other, creating a virtuous cycle of optimization.

The Bottom Line

Choosing between Amazon and Walmart ultimately depends on your business objectives, industry, and risk tolerance. Amazon offers unmatched volume potential but in an ultra-competitive environment. Walmart provides a more peaceful alternative with better margins but lower traffic.

The real opportunity might lie in a hybrid approach: start with Walmart to test your products and build your reputation, then expand to Amazon once your strategy is refined.

Ready to launch your business on the right marketplace? Download our free guide “10 Steps to Success on Amazon and Walmart” and discover the exact strategies used by sellers generating over $100K in monthly revenue.

---

Share this article if it helped clarify your decision, and tell us in the comments: which platform will you choose to grow your business?